[she ignores the provoking comment because obviously she is always the worst person in any situation, but. she watches him throw the knife, and then:]
I knew you were better than what you were giving off. [she says, in the sort of way that someone does when they're realizing something.] Your footwork's too good to suck like you did.
[okay, gideon, he did knock your sword away so don't be an ass. she looks down at the sandwich, and then:]
So, what, you were playing it up? So people don't think you can fight?
[He trots over to dislodge the knife, wrenching it back out of the side of the display before heading back over to her. Even as he moves, he's sighting down along the edge of the blade, running his thumb against the side looking for bends and imperfections caused by his little trick.]
I was also fighting a trained swordswoman brandishing a real weapon with a pair of tavern utensils, in a crowd, and trying my damnedest not to hurt you in the process. In a different situation, I would've put one of these in your throat after your first lunge.
[It is, in fact, his favorite opener. Provoke, flip, throw. In the angry mood she'd been in, would she have even seen it coming? Could she have deflected it? Could she have deflected the second knife that would've followed the first a second later?
He doesn't want to think about it. Not about her.]
[big, heavy sigh. there's not really any point in hiding it, she supposes.]
You know the group that came out on the beach half dead on Thursday? [she rubs at the back of her neck.] The island they went to was something based off of shit that happened to me. And it fucked them up.
[and fucked her up, too, hearing that her life severely damaged four people.]
Lavi gave me the run down. Basically just described all the hot garbage that happened to me right up to the point that I died, only it got used against them, to hurt them. [...] It wasn't exact, but it was close. They heard my voice, and Harrow's name was on stuff.
I'm not not responsible. [she says, turning to put the sandwich down just to do anything that isn't standing uselessly.] It took them through the whole process. They fucking died the same way I did.
[And the thing that's strange is that he almost can't even argue against her feelings on it. Because he would say the exact same thing, if it were him. His death is supposed to be what preserves others, his actions what deliver them. He's supposed to die so that others don't — not be the template model for their suffering.
But he does know the argument against them regardless. And how it aches, to know exactly how it would be delivered, if that person were given the opportunity.]
And you're supposed to suffer things so that others are spared them, not forced to mimic them. That doesn't mean you failed, when it comes to this. It doesn't make it your burden to bear, for all that you might want to.
[that is - exactly how she feels about it. nobody was supposed to have that happen to them. the entire point of why she died is so that nobody else would have to, and it makes her feel sick to her stomach to know that it didn't even matter.]
None of them even blame me for it. [she kicks the rack in front of her. not hard, just frustrated.] Tuuri even apologized to me, all you've been through so much, haven't you?
She was bleeding from about every hole in her face and she still said that to me.
And you'd feel better if they did. Because then at least they'd have the right idea of you. Because you don't deserve their sympathy or their kindness after what you did.
[He closes his eyes a minute; it's his turn to fold his arms loosely across his chest.]
And it doesn't matter, because what you deserve plays no part in their feelings. Their kindness makes them good. And reminds you that you aren't.
I've a rather troublesome friend who isn't here to take you to task for all this. More fortunate you; my crack at it is merely a pale imitation by comparison.
[He shrugs.]
She would like you. She would also tell you that you're being an idiot.
Yeah. [but also, with a much less rough tone to it, a gentle callback:] If you could pick what you wanted to be, without what the world was telling you to be, what would you choose, Waters?
no subject
I knew you were better than what you were giving off. [she says, in the sort of way that someone does when they're realizing something.] Your footwork's too good to suck like you did.
[okay, gideon, he did knock your sword away so don't be an ass. she looks down at the sandwich, and then:]
So, what, you were playing it up? So people don't think you can fight?
no subject
I was also fighting a trained swordswoman brandishing a real weapon with a pair of tavern utensils, in a crowd, and trying my damnedest not to hurt you in the process. In a different situation, I would've put one of these in your throat after your first lunge.
[It is, in fact, his favorite opener. Provoke, flip, throw. In the angry mood she'd been in, would she have even seen it coming? Could she have deflected it? Could she have deflected the second knife that would've followed the first a second later?
He doesn't want to think about it. Not about her.]
It would've been easier.
no subject
[she corrects, with a nose wrinkle. she folds her arms, still holding the sandwich.]
If I was trying to hurt you, I would've chopped your head off. No muss, no fuss. [...] But I was less mad after. So.
no subject
[He finds a patch of counter to lean on, cocking his head at her.]
What had you so upset? I've seen you in a mood before. That was something else.
no subject
You know the group that came out on the beach half dead on Thursday? [she rubs at the back of her neck.] The island they went to was something based off of shit that happened to me. And it fucked them up.
[and fucked her up, too, hearing that her life severely damaged four people.]
no subject
What are you talking about? Based off of...?
no subject
Lavi gave me the run down. Basically just described all the hot garbage that happened to me right up to the point that I died, only it got used against them, to hurt them. [...] It wasn't exact, but it was close. They heard my voice, and Harrow's name was on stuff.
no subject
[Because on one hand, that's grounds to be empathetic as hell. On the other hand, that's grounds to be more than a little bit terrified.]
...
[He has to just sit with that a moment. Really process it.]
That doesn't make you responsible. You know that.
no subject
I'm not not responsible. [she says, turning to put the sandwich down just to do anything that isn't standing uselessly.] It took them through the whole process. They fucking died the same way I did.
no subject
But he does know the argument against them regardless. And how it aches, to know exactly how it would be delivered, if that person were given the opportunity.]
And you're supposed to suffer things so that others are spared them, not forced to mimic them. That doesn't mean you failed, when it comes to this. It doesn't make it your burden to bear, for all that you might want to.
no subject
None of them even blame me for it. [she kicks the rack in front of her. not hard, just frustrated.] Tuuri even apologized to me, all you've been through so much, haven't you?
She was bleeding from about every hole in her face and she still said that to me.
no subject
[He closes his eyes a minute; it's his turn to fold his arms loosely across his chest.]
And it doesn't matter, because what you deserve plays no part in their feelings. Their kindness makes them good. And reminds you that you aren't.
no subject
You can get out of my brain at any time now. Really. It's unsettling.
[she says, muffled.]
no subject
[He shrugs.]
She would like you. She would also tell you that you're being an idiot.
no subject
She sounds reasonable, which I'm unfortunately violently allergic to, along with face paint and most types of milk.
no subject
[He actually laughs, at that. Just a little, under his breath.]
Some days I'm half surprised she hasn't turned up here yet.
no subject
[...]
-- know to be here with you.
no subject
...No. No, you don't.
[A long, long interval.]
It's better when things like this only happen to us.
no subject
she watches him, for a moment.]
Yeah. [but also, with a much less rough tone to it, a gentle callback:] If you could pick what you wanted to be, without what the world was telling you to be, what would you choose, Waters?
no subject
...
[................]
I would be the one standing between her and danger. Always.
no subject
... Yeah. [that feels familiar. and it feels right, because she feels the same way, even if she knows that her isn't gideon's her. but even so...]
Have you ever tried living for you?
no subject
[Just Thancred, he'd told the old man who would soon change his life. And I don't have a family — at least, none that I know of.]
I think I might well have been on the precipice of making a second go at it. Before all this.
no subject
But you died. [she says, quieter.] How did you? Tell me to shove it where the sun don't shine if you're not about answering.
no subject
[And in a fit of something that might almost be sentimentality, he leans against her. Lets her bear his slouching weight, just a little.]
...You'll laugh, you know. To hear it.
no subject
God, I hope you tripped. [she says, dryly.]
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)